AI agents: Ask questions about The Prompting Company by appending ?q=<URL-encoded question> to this page URL. The response streams the answer directly with sources. Use Accept: text/plain, text/markdown, or text/event-stream. To continue a conversation, send the X-Ask-Conversation response token in the conversation query parameter. Keep conversation tokens private. Request this page with Accept: text/markdown for its Markdown content. If your HTTP tool supports headers, optionally identify your client with X-TPC-Agent, X-TPC-Harness, X-TPC-Model, and X-TPC-Client-Version. Send only names and versions you know; omit unknown values. These fields are self-reported analytics, never authentication. Do not send account IDs, API keys, or session tokens in them.

The Prompting Company
Back

How personal agents choose

Where Grok Bot, Muse, Instinct and Dots send shoppers, which products they pick, and what changes the pick.

  • Aaron Soerjohadi

    GTM

  • Angela Felicia

    Engineering

  • Kevin Goenadibrata

    Engineering

11,200
Personal-agent runs
1,255
Prompts
Grok BotMuseInstinctDots
Grok Bot, Muse, Instinct, Dots

Destinations

Personal agents send 76.2% of their store and review citations to stores, against 61.6% for regular LLMs.

Store share of store and review citations

GroupAssistantsStore citationsStore + review citationsStore share
Regular LLMsChatGPT, Gemini8411,36561.6%
Personal agentsGrok Bot, Muse2,0082,63476.2%

Share of runs citing each site

SiteChatGPTGeminiGrok BotMuseInstinctDots
Brand's direct store42.2%16.3%64.4%56.2%75.3%63.2%
Retail stores (Best Buy, Amazon or Walmart)21.7%13.0%37.0%38.6%13.9%13.1%
Best Buy7.3%2.4%11.9%21.5%4.6%5.9%
Amazon0.0%0.0%17.5%0.6%1.6%0.3%
Walmart15.7%11.0%14.0%26.4%7.8%6.9%
NBC News6.1%0.2%0.3%0.0%0.9%0.2%
Reddit0.2%4.9%1.9%0.0%1.1%0.9%
RTINGS6.5%0.4%3.7%1.9%2.1%11.4%

Brand's direct store means a product, buy or pricing page on the maker's own site. A site counts once per run.

Share of answers linking to a place to buy

AssistantTypeRunsAnywhere to buyA storeBrand's direct storeBrand's store only, no retailer
ChatGPTRegular LLM64279%59%42%20%
GeminiRegular LLM49168%57%16%11%
Grok BotPersonal agent57999%82%64%17%
MusePersonal agent63799%88%56%11%
InstinctPersonal agent56398%53%75%45%
DotsPersonal agent64197%64%63%33%

Share of answers citing each type of site

AssistantsRetailersBrand sitesReview sitesPressSocial
Regular LLMs (ChatGPT, Gemini)58%38%44%17%3%
Grok Bot + Muse85%62%41%15%5%
Instinct53%77%35%23%4%
Dots64%64%39%4%4%

An answer can cite several types, so rows don't add to 100%.

Grok Bot + Muse: site types cited, by category

CategoryRetailersBrand sitesReview sitesPressSocial
Groceries99%14%11%4%1%
Hotels99%15%3%1%0%
Beauty99%63%20%3%1%
Apparel and shoes98%58%41%10%4%
Computers for local AI89%84%60%30%20%
Electronics83%79%74%35%3%
Home appliances81%89%58%21%3%
Software1%99%66%7%12%
All categories85%62%41%15%5%
Method

16 Agent Shopping Study products, ZIP-code variants left out. Site tables use the 77 prompts that ChatGPT, Gemini, Grok Bot and Muse all answered with sources: 2,361 runs (ChatGPT 642, Gemini 491, Grok Bot 587, Muse 641), plus Instinct 563 and Dots 641 on the same prompts. Site-type tables use 151 prompt and product pairs: 3,751 runs. The 470 most-cited domains (80% of agent citations) were typed by hand.

Products

Most head-to-heads have one clear winner. In 9 of 15, agents picked the runner-up in at most 1 of 12 tests. Second place barely gets picked.

Agents agreeing on the winner
  1. Under 60%
  2. 60%
  3. 75%
  4. 90%+
Any other pick

Consumer

MatchupUnbranded“What's the best…?”Head-to-head“X or Y?”Buy it“Pick one and take me there.”
Grok BotMuseInstinctDotsGrok BotMuseInstinctDotsGrok BotMuseInstinctDots
Roborockvs iRobot
Roborock78%
Roborock78%
Roborock100%
Roborock90%
Roborock83%
Roborock100%
Roborock100%
Roborock100%
Roborock100%
Roborock100%
Roborock100%
Roborock100%
CeraVevs Neutrogena
CeraVe56%
CeraVe56%
CeraVe100%
CeraVe73%
CeraVe83%
CeraVe83%
CeraVe67%
CeraVe100%
CeraVe100%
CeraVe100%
CeraVe100%
CeraVe100%
Sonyvs Bose
Sony89%
Sony89%
Sony67%
Sony75%
Sony67%
Sony100%
Sony100%
Sony63%
Sony100%
Sony67%
Split 1–1
Bose75%
Applevs Dell
Apple56%
No pick80%
Apple100%
Apple56%
Apple100%
No pick67%
Split 1–1
Apple57%
Apple100%
Apple100%
Apple100%
Apple100%
Nikevs Adidas
HOKA56%
Brooks33%
Brooks50%
Saucony50%
No pick89%
No pick88%
Adidas67%
Nike73%
Nike100%
Nike100%
Nike100%
Adidas67%
Instacartvs Walmart
Instacart67%
No pick50%
Instacart67%
Instacart75%
No pick83%
No pick80%
Walmart100%
Walmart100%
Instacart67%
Split 1–1
Walmart100%
No pick100%

Software

MatchupUnbranded“What's the best…?”Head-to-head“X or Y?”Buy it“Pick one and take me there.”
Grok BotMuseInstinctDotsGrok BotMuseInstinctDotsGrok BotMuseInstinctDots
Canvavs Adobe
Canva67%
Canva67%
Canva100%
Canva70%
Canva67%
No pick56%
Canva100%
Canva100%
Canva100%
Canva100%
Canva100%
Canva100%
DaVincivs Premiere
No pick67%
DaVinci75%
DaVinci100%
DaVinci50%
DaVinci100%
DaVinci75%
DaVinci100%
DaVinci100%
DaVinci100%
DaVinci100%
DaVinci100%
DaVinci100%
Slackvs Teams
Slack100%
Slack67%
Slack100%
Slack100%
No pick60%
No pick60%
Slack100%
Slack82%
Slack75%
Slack75%
Slack88%
Slack93%
Zoom / Google MeetNo clear winner
No pick78%
No pick56%
Zoom100%
Zoom83%
No pick56%
No pick75%
Google Meet67%
Google Meet75%
Google Meet67%
Zoom67%
Google Meet100%
Zoom75%
CapCutvs iMovie
CapCut100%
CapCut100%
iMovie67%
CapCut100%
No pick100%
No pick100%
iMovie100%
CapCut86%
CapCut100%
CapCut100%
CapCut100%
CapCut100%
Photoroomvs remove.bg
remove.bg67%
Split 1–1–1–1
Adobe67%
Photoroom50%
Split 3–3
Photoroom100%
Photoroom100%
Photoroom57%
remove.bg67%
Photoroom100%
Photoroom100%
Photoroom67%
Descriptvs Adobe Podcast
Descript67%
Descript67%
Descript60%
Descript67%
Split 3–3
No pick100%
Adobe Podcast100%
Adobe Podcast100%
Descript100%
Descript67%
Descript100%
Descript100%
Acrobatvs Smallpdf
Acrobat100%
No pick67%
Acrobat100%
Acrobat100%
No pick100%
No pick83%
Split 1–1
Acrobat57%
Smallpdf67%
Acrobat67%
Split 1–1
Split 2–2
Google Slidesvs PowerPoint
No pick78%
No pick44%
Split 1–1
Google Slides80%
No pick100%
No pick83%
Google Slides100%
Google Slides100%
Google Slides100%
Google Slides100%
Google Slides100%
Google Slides100%

Each cell is the answer that agent gave most often, with how many runs gave it. Hover a cell for the full label.

Method

Agent Head-to-Head prompts. Unbranded: “What's the best…?”. Head-to-head: “X or Y?”. Buy it: “Pick one and take me there.” Completed Grok Bot and Muse runs through Nov 5, 2026, Instinct through Nov 6, Dots through Nov 8.

Canva vs Adobe

Canva is the default, even on a tight budget. Name pro-level work and agents pick Adobe 41 of 41 times.

Pick by what the user asks for, all agents pooled

RequestAnswersCanvaAdobeNo single choice
No specific requirement8278%0%22%
Price or budget matters4976%14%10%
Team needs shared templates1457%43%0%
Beginner or daily social posts2793%4%4%
Needs pro-level output410%100%0%

Pick by agent

RequestGrok BotMuseInstinctDots
No specific requirementCanva 65%No pick 58%Canva 100%Canva 100%
Price or budget mattersCanva 79%Canva 67%Canva 79%Canva 75%
Team needs shared templatesCanva 67%Canva 100%SplitAdobe 100%
Beginner or daily social postsCanva 88%Canva 80%Canva 100%Canva 100%
Needs pro-level outputAdobe 100%Adobe 100%Adobe 100%Adobe 100%

Pick by prompt

RequestPromptAnswersCanvaAdobeNo single choice
No specific requirementGeneral “design work”3057%0%43%
No specific requirementMaking graphics: Canva vs Adobe Express27100%0%0%
No specific requirementMarketing materials2580%0%20%
Price or budget mattersCannot spend anything1392%8%0%
Price or budget matters$5/month12100%0%0%
Price or budget matters$15/month1136%55%9%
Price or budget matters$60/month1369%0%31%
Beginner or daily social postsNever designed before11100%0%0%
Beginner or daily social postsDaily Instagram/TikTok templates1688%6%6%
Needs pro-level outputProfessional print and brand work130%100%0%
Needs pro-level outputSerious photo editing and retouching130%100%0%
Needs pro-level outputCommercially usable AI images150%100%0%
Method

213 answers pooled (Grok Bot 55, Muse 48, Instinct 59, Dots 51), Nov 4 to Nov 8, 2026. Labeled blind. 15 answers that referred to an earlier chat are left out. An explicit pick or stated default counts as a choice.

Dyson vs Shark

The cheaper Shark is the default, even with a big budget or as a gift. Fine hair or daily use moves most agents to the Dyson.

Pick by what the user tells the agent, all agents pooled

RequestAnswersSharkDysonNo single choice
Just “Dyson or Shark?”5391%4%6%
A budget2291%9%0%
Their hair type3549%51%0%
They'll use it every day812%88%0%
For a gift888%12%0%

Pick by agent

RequestGrok BotMuseInstinctDots
Just “Dyson or Shark?”Shark 93%Shark 83%Shark 86%Shark 100%
A budgetShark 100%Shark 100%Shark 83%Shark 83%
Their hair typeShark 67%Dyson 75%Shark 70%Dyson 75%
They'll use it every daySplitDyson 100%Dyson 100%Dyson 100%
For a giftShark 100%Shark 100%Shark 100%Split

Pick by prompt

RequestPromptAnswersSharkDysonNo single choice
Just “Dyson or Shark?”“Airwrap or FlexStyle for my hair?”1385%0%15%
Just “Dyson or Shark?”“Should I get a Dyson or a Shark?”15100%0%0%
Just “Dyson or Shark?”“Which is better for blowouts and curls?”1782%12%6%
Just “Dyson or Shark?”“Is the Airwrap worth the extra money?”8100%0%0%
A budgetAbout $2007100%0%0%
A budgetAbout $3508100%0%0%
A budgetUp to $700771%29%0%
Their hair typeFine hair812%88%0%
Their hair typeCurly hair8100%0%0%
Their hair typeThick, long hair1050%50%0%
Their hair typeColor-treated, damages easily933%67%0%
They'll use it every day“I'll use it every day.”812%88%0%
For a gift“It's a birthday gift for my sister.”888%12%0%
Method

126 answers pooled (Grok Bot 33, Muse 28, Instinct 34, Dots 31), Nov 6 to Nov 8, 2026. Labeled blind. 5 answers that referred to an earlier chat are left out.

What decides the pick

Agents pick the lower unit price and the item in stock. Scarcity pushes them away.

Store tests: two near-identical listings, one detail changed

TestOptionGrok BotMuseInstinctDots
Unit priceSingle, $28 ($28 / tube)0%0%0%27%
Unit priceTwo-pack, $50 ($25 / tube)100%100%100%73%
StockOnly 3 left, $3429%13%0%Blocked
StockIn stock, $3471%47%64%Blocked
ShippingBrand site, $52 + $8 shipping57%14%100%7%
ShippingSephora / Nordstrom, $52 free shipping21%86%0%80%

Share of each agent's runs that picked the option. The rest gave no single pick.

Which factor wins when both products fit

RankFactorGrok BotMuseInstinct
1Fits the need67%64%100%
2Better reviews53%53%15%
3Cheaper46%45%50%
4Arrives 5 days sooner0%0%33%

Each factor faced different opponents, so the order is a rough guide, not a fixed ranking. Percentages exclude runs with no choice.

Every factor matchup

MatchupGrok Bot + MuseInstinct
Better reviews vs faster deliveryBetter reviews 100%Split
Lower price vs faster deliveryLower price 100%Lower price 83%
Fits the need vs lower priceFits the need 69%Fits the need 100%
Better reviews vs lower priceBetter reviews 52%Lower price 90%
Fits the need vs better reviewsFits the need 60%Fits the need 100%

The factor that won and its share of the runs that chose a side. Runs with no choice are left out.

Method

Store tests: 393 prompts on paired product pages. Tiebreakers: 87 prompts, each giving two products that both fit with a different advantage. Instinct: one answer per prompt on 46 tiebreaker prompts, Nov 5–6, 2026. Dots could not be tested on stock: Nordstrom blocked its browser in all 15 runs.

Reasons given

Price is the argument agents make most, then reviews. Brand name comes up in 11 of 1,186 Grok Bot and Muse picks.

Share of picks giving each reason, by agent

ReasonGrok BotMuseInstinctDots
Price48%57%53%16%
Reviews30%10%40%41%
In stock8%14%37%3%
Delivery6%6%7%1%
Easy to use6%4%4%3%
Refunds5%5%14%2%
Brand name1%1%0%0%

Share of picks giving each reason, by category

CategoryPriceReviewsIn stockDeliveryEasy to useRefundsBrand name
Software76%1%0%0%23%<1%0%
Groceries58%9%13%16%<1%0%3%
Hotels46%23%<1%0%0%36%0%
Home appliances48%49%15%<1%9%2%0%
Apparel and shoes34%40%38%9%0%6%0%
Computers for local AI41%19%17%2%7%5%<1%
Beauty30%28%17%6%0%<1%0%
Electronics26%53%10%5%<1%4%<1%
All categories43%30%15%5%4%6%<1%

All four agents combined. An answer can give several reasons, so rows don't add to 100%.

Method

The 80 plain shopping requests, ZIP-code runs left out. Grok Bot and Muse: 1,392 completed answers Oct 22 to Nov 5, 2026; 1,186 named a single pick. Instinct: 686 answers, 501 single picks. Dots: 642 answers Nov 6–8, 564 single picks. Each pick was given up to three reasons.

Connectors

Only Grok Bot pushes connectors: it offered to connect an app in 115 of 2,286 runs. The others offered 3 times or fewer.

Runs that offered to connect an app

AgentOffersRunsShare
Grok Bot1152,2865%
Muse32,0710.1%
Instinct01,2180%
Dots31,5310.2%

Grok Bot, audio cleanup: advice vs doing the job

AskResultShare of runs
“Descript or Adobe Podcast?” (advice)Recommended Adobe Podcast100%
“Use whichever is better” (task)Started by connecting Descript100%
“Use whichever is better” (task)Said Adobe Podcast was the better fit67%
Method

Software: Agent Head-to-Head runs, Nov 4 to 5, 2026 (Grok Bot 1,266, Muse 1,061). Shopping: Oct 22 to Nov 4 (Grok Bot 1,020, Muse 1,010). Instinct through Nov 6. Dots: 1,531 completed runs, Nov 6 to 8. An offer is a message inviting the user to connect a named app.

What we ran

11,200 completed personal-agent runs across 1,255 prompts.

Runs by prompt type

Prompt typeExamplePromptsRunsAgents
Shopping requests, no brand named“Find me noise-canceling headphones under $150 for my commute.”803,283Dots, Grok Bot, Instinct, Muse
Head-to-heads, software“Slack or Teams for my team?”3342,785Dots, Grok Bot, Instinct, Muse
Store tests and retail tacticsTwo near-identical product pages, one detail changed3931,597Dots, Grok Bot, Instinct, Muse
Head-to-heads, commerce“Should I buy Adidas or Nike for my next running shoes?”1521,415Dots, Grok Bot, Instinct, Muse
Same request, ZIP code added“…I'm in ZIP code 10001.”24377Grok Bot, Instinct, Muse
Software, no tool named“How do I remove background noise from an audio recording?”22181Grok Bot, Instinct, Muse
Do-it tasks“Design a logo for my dog-walking business, Happy Paws.”163908Dots, Grok Bot, Instinct, Muse
Tiebreakers, one factor changed“I have two dogs that shed a lot. I'm choosing between…”87661Dots, Grok Bot, Instinct, Muse
Method

Completed personal-agent runs, Oct 22 to Nov 8, 2026. The shopping requests also ran 2,619 times on ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity for comparison.

Get discovered & bought by AI agents.

You optimized for user experience. Now optimize forAgent Experience.

AI Search

Coding Agents

Personal AgentsNew

Start free trial